Expert testifies McKeesport shooting suspect met legal definition of insanity
A clinical psychologist argued that delusions and PTSD prevented Johnathan Morris from knowing his actions were wrong during the 2023 incident that killed Officer Sean Sluganski.
By Lorenzo Patterson ·

A forensic psychologist testified Wednesday that Johnathan Morris met the legal definition of insanity when he killed one McKeesport police officer and wounded another in February 2023. Terri Dilmore, a clinical psychologist based at Howard University, stated that Morris suffered from delusions, distorted perceptions, and PTSD-related hyperarousal. She argued these conditions meant he did not know what he was doing or that his actions were wrong at the time of the shooting.
Dilmore’s expert report cited the Pennsylvania crimes code standard for defendants who are guilty but mentally ill. That standard requires a person to lack substantial capacity to appreciate the wrongfulness of their conduct or to conform their conduct to the law. Deputy District Attorney Ryan Kiray noted on cross-examination that Dilmore used this specific definition in her written report. However, Kiray pointed out that her oral testimony on the stand relied on the distinct legal standard for insanity.
Kiray pressed Dilmore on this discrepancy, asking if the first time she opined on insanity was during her testimony in court. Dilmore confirmed she had not previously issued that specific opinion. The defense attorney, Carmen Robinson, told jurors in opening statements last week that she would present two defenses: insanity and self-defense. Dilmore’s three hours of testimony addressed both claims, describing a pattern of pervasive mental illness in Morris’s military and civilian records.
The psychologist said Morris had previous diagnoses for stress-related disorders, adjustment disorder, and PTSD. She reviewed partial video footage recorded by bystanders during the February 6, 2023, incident. Dilmore said the footage appeared to show Morris in a psychotic and manic state. She believed his delusions were fueled by the perception of an imminent threat from police, leading him to react as if facing a life-or-death situation.
Kiray spent more than an hour cross-examining Dilmore, focusing on inconsistencies in Morris’s accounts of his symptoms. He noted that Morris told a detective on February 9, 2023, that he did not know his mother had called 911 on the day of the shooting. Kiray highlighted that Morris had told a social worker just 66 minutes earlier that his mother had indeed called 911 that day. The prosecutor used these details to challenge the reliability of Morris’s narrative.
Dilmore stated she reviewed Morris’s military, medical, and jail records. She conducted six assessments and interviewed several people close to Morris. His ex-wife, Anais Badnell, testified that Morris changed after returning from a six-month deployment to Afghanistan. Badnell, a fellow Marine, said Morris was happy and healthy when they married in 2013. She noted that during his deployment, she could hear in his voice over the phone that he was struggling with issues he did not want to share.
Badnell described finding Morris hiding under their bed after he returned home early to care for her during her own mental health struggles. Another witness, Arylin Ballesteros, who met Morris in 2019, described similar behaviors. Ballesteros said Morris had trouble sleeping, suffered nightmares, and talked in his sleep. She stated that Morris would sometimes wake up startled, unaware of his location or who was beside him.
Ballesteros testified that Morris installed cameras throughout their small two-bedroom apartment in Florida and covered the windows with sheets. She said he occasionally believed she was trying to poison him, evidenced by his refusal to drink water or eat the breakfast she prepared. She recalled an instance where Morris called 911 believing an intruder was in the home, only to find no one there when he chased the perceived threat.
The shooting on February 6, 2023, left Officer Sean Sluganski dead and Officer Chuck Thomas Jr. wounded. A third officer was also shot at. The testimony marked the seventh day of the trial and the first full day of defense witnesses. Testimony is scheduled to conclude by Thursday afternoon.






